Rent: The Movie Version That *Doesn't* Suck

If you were, like me, deeply disappointed in the 2005 movie version of "Rent," then you'll be very happy to learn that the new filmed version, called "Rent: Filmed Live on Broadway," is infinitely better. It has its quirks and flaws, but on the whole, it's a thrilling document of a landmark show.

The film starts off a bit creaky, with the actors playing a bit too much to the cameras. Or perhaps that was just a sign of my need to get used to what is in fact a new medium: a "live" film of a Broadway musical being shown in a local movie theater. But, to me, it seemed that people were breaking character at first, as if to say, "Isn't it cool we're filming this!", and exhibiting an annoying "Yeah, man!" enthusiasm when they're singing songs about how miserable their lives are. For the most part, the filming didn't call attention to itself, allowing the power of the show to speak for itself.  

But once the power of the piece kicked in, I was reminded of what a terrific show Rent is: the setting, the emotions, the relationships, the subtext. It's a rich and complexly executed show, performed with admirable restraint by the mostly strong final Broadway cast. I haven't seen the show in a few years, and as I sat watching the film, I was reminded that certain parts of Rent are incredibly well written, including the "I Should Tell You" duet during the "La Vie Boheme" sequence. There's also some stuff that's hackneyed and lame, including "Happy New Year" and the almost unbearable scene after the funeral. ("You have to learn to love yourself," and all that crap. Yeesh.)

But the dynamic final cast somehow made even the lamest of lines work. In fact, some of them were even better than their original-cast counterparts. Particularly good were Will Chase (Roger), Adam Kantor (Mark), Renée Elise Goldsberry (Mimi), and Justin Johnston (Angel). Chase brought more vocal and dramatic modulation to the part than Adam Pascal, and Johnston found much more humor in the role of Angel than I recall from Tony winner Wilson Jermaine Heredia.

I must begrudgingly admit that Eden Espinosa as Maureen was surprisingly effective. I've never been a fan of her particular brand of vocal histrionics, but she kept her excesses in check, and made for a effective foil to Tracie Thoms' likewise serviceable Joanne. Michael McElroy as Collins may have fallen victim to my heightened expectations. The second act reprise of "I'll Cover You" is one of the most moving moments in musical-theater history, but McElroy's rendition didn't really do it for me. Even so, I still found myself blubbering through most of the second act, overwhelmed by the sheer power of the story, the performers, and Jonathan Larson's kick-ass score.

"Rent: Filmed Live on Broadway" plays this Saturday and Sunday, September 27th and 28th, literally at a theater near you. No word yet on whether there are plans to release the film on DVD. But I'm sincerely hoping that they do.

Comments

[Esther]

Hey Chris,
Thanks for the great review. I'm going to see it on Sunday, so I'm glad you liked it! One thing that mystifies me a bit - I haven't seen any advertising for it. The showing isn't even included in the newspaper ad that lists the movie theatre's schedule. But I know it's playing there because I already bought my ticket. I wonder why it's not being promoted more?

[Joseph Gomez]

I completely agree with you on everything you mention here. On my blog I wrote of the flaws of the show, the dreadful movie version, and the superb cinecast.

I went on Saturday (again San Antonio, TX here) and there were no more than 12 people in the theater. My friends and I were 4 of them.

Is it me or does Adam Kantor sound exactly like a less annoying Anthony Rapp? :-)

[the anti mama Rose]

Lily tried to go see it this past weekend. I had looked it up and told Bill where it was playing, but when he called to get tickets they told him it was the original movie. They said Idina Menzel was in it. I suspect it was really what you saw as it was only playing Th through Sun, but they skipped it. How confusing.

[Esther]

Wow, the poor marketing of this on the part of Sony is just unbelievable.

[chris caggiano]

You know, it's funny, but the showing I attended in Boston on Wednesday night was practically sold out. I guess there's more of a theater audience in Boston. I certainly don't recall it being advertised. I think I found out about it on Playbill.com or one of the other sites.

Perhaps this means that they'll have to release it on DVD to amortize their costs.

I hope they don't come to the conclusion that there isn't an audience for this sort of thing, but rather that they didn't market it correctly.

[Steven]

I saw this cast live and in the film, and McElroy's "I'll Cover You (Reprise)" was so electric and moving live. It's really a shame that it did not translate to film. And many other moments that I loved live didn't translate either. If anything, this film made me extremely fond of when I saw the show the day before it closed. Thanks for the review.

~Steven